The Disadvantages of Reverse Osmosis in Agricultural Applications

August 30, 2019

Reverse osmosis is an effective way to purify water, but presents serious shortcomings in agriculture and other applications with large-scale water demands.

Reverse osmosis is a time-tested means of purifying water at scales ranging from residential to industrial, for a variety of applications including manufacturing, agriculture, and human consumption. Regardless of the size of the reverse osmosis system, the process is largely the same: pressure is used to force water through a membrane with pores so small that water can pass through, but bacteria, viruses, and molecules of contaminants like heavy metals are left behind.

This approach is very effective at purifying and decontaminating water. However, reverse osmosis presents serious shortcomings that become increasingly obvious as the scale of water demand increases.

Reverse osmosis systems are labor intensive and costly to maintain, especially the membranes.

Of the most maintenance-intensive elements of a reverse osmosis system is the filter. The holes in the filter are incredibly tiny—only about one ten-billionth of a meter across. For comparison, the thickness of a piece of paper is about a million times greater.

It shouldn’t come as a surprise that the membranes frequently become clogged, especially when the water source is of a lower quality. When this happens, the membranes must be cleaned frequently. Failing to appropriately clean and maintain a reverse osmosis membrane can result in bacteria growing through the membrane, which compromises the filtered water. Mineral buildup can also occur, and during a cleaning cycle, the cleaner used will react with the minerals and eat holes in the membrane, irreparably damaging it.

Regardless of how well you maintain the membrane, it will still have to be replaced. When well maintained and used with a higher quality water source, a membrane may last about five years. But the performance of a membrane has to be monitored, and it may have to be replaced earlier than anticipated if it no longer meets filtration specifications.

Replacing a single membrane in a larger scale system typically costs $2,000 to $3,000. With industrial-scale systems, membrane replacement costs are significantly higher. Industrial scale systems rely on multiple membranes—anywhere from 3 to dozens—and replacing a set of 3 membranes can cost $10,000 when factoring in parts, labor, and lost productivity.

It should also be noted that the performance of reverse osmosis membranes can be compromised by water sources or operating conditions with inconsistent temperatures. In warmer water conditions, the pores of the membrane will expand, allowing larger particles to pass through. In cooler conditions, the pores will shrink and filter out smaller contaminants, but will also make the pump work harder.

Membrane replacement isn’t the only significant maintenance cost associated with reverse osmosis systems. The pump that generates the pressures needed to force water through the membrane requires occasional servicing, due to the wear and tear from running the system.

Immense amounts of waste water are generated by reverse osmosis systems, and sometimes this waste water must be disposed of in a manner complying with state and federal regulations.

For a reverse osmosis system to generate pure water, it must ‘reject’ a certain amount of water, depending on the application and desired quality of water. Reverse osmosis systems used for agricultural irrigation can generally be set to reject much less water than a system used for industrial applications. But the amount of wasted water is still quite high.

Let’s say that a reverse osmosis system produces 1 gallon of waste water for every gallon of purified water it produces (in many cases, this is a pretty conservative estimate). This level of waste doesn’t pose an issue for the average homeowner. But in agricultural applications—whether you’re irrigating crops in the field or supplying water to an indoor hydroponics system—this level of waste is immensely costly. For every gallon of purified water produced, you’re dumping a gallon of water. This is unsustainable for many growers, especially those that have limited water allotments.

Then there’s the matter of disposing of the waste water. Depending on the water source, waste water produced by a reverse osmosis system can be dangerous. For instance, if the salt content of the water source is high, the waste water will have potentially toxic levels of salt and may require processing before it can be discharged. Other contaminants can be a serious problem as well. We have personally worked with a client with a well that has levels of arsenic higher than the EPA’s safe limit. Using a reverse osmosis system with this water source would be unwise, as the waste water would have higher levels of arsenic, and be a major liability for the well owner.

Water processed by a reverse osmosis system is stripped of numerous beneficial minerals and has an acidic pH.

While reverse osmosis is great at removing harmful contaminants from water, it also strips out all other minerals. When water from a reverse osmosis system is used for irrigation, it leaches minerals out of the soil or growing media, including calcium and other minerals critical to healthy plant growth. This creates additional costs for growers, as the lost minerals must be supplemented.

Ensuring ideal growing conditions is complicated by the fact that reverse osmosis lowers the pH of processed water to as low as 5 (neutral pH is 7). This presents a problem, as plants generally prefer a pH of around 5.5 to 7. Dropping below that 5.5 level results in nutrients leaching, which of course exacerbates the leaching that occurs due to the mineral-free nature of reverse osmosis-derived water.

Reverse osmosis does not remove all bacteria, viruses, and fungal spores.

The reverse osmosis process is very efficient at removing a wide variety of contaminants, including pathogens. However, it is not 100% effective. A very small percentage of microorganisms may pass through the membrane due to manufacturing imperfections (which is why manufacturers are  careful to not guarantee the removal of all pathogens).

In addition, damage or failure of seals can allow small amounts of water to pass through the system untreated. For growers who need to eliminate potential fungal contamination—especially cannabis growers, who work in warm environments highly conducive to fungal and mold growth—this presents a serious problem.

For growers and other businesses that need a better water purification solution, ozonated water systems offer a solution.

Watson Well has been around for many years, and in that time, we’ve had the opportunity to speak with countless clients about their many different types of water purification systems, including reverse osmosis systems of all sizes and types.

Reverse osmosis is a perfectly acceptable way to deliver small amounts of purified water for home use. However, its extreme inefficiency and high cost of use poses serious problems for users with large-scale needs. We have had the opportunity to work with growers and other commercial users who were extremely frustrated with their systems,  blindsided by the shortcomings and additional costs of reverse osmosis.

This is why we take a different approach to large-scale water treatment, with our ozonated agricultural water treatment systems. Rather than relying on costly, service-intensive filtration membranes, our systems use high levels of ozone to kill all pathogens in the water, while oxidizing (and neutralizing) heavy metals and other contaminants.

The result is a water treatment solution that requires far less maintenance, is cheaper to operate, and can deliver a far greater flow rate than comparable reverse osmosis systems. We invite you to take some time to learn more about ozone water treatment, or contact us today to learn how we can help you meet the water needs of your farm, business, or agricultural operation.

We can count on them more than any other contractor or service provider we know!

Don Watson and his family have been providing experienced and reliable service to our well-water system since 2011. In those seven years, Watson Well has made a number of timely emergency service calls at any time of day and night, upgraded our water system, and rehabilitated our well.

Mr and Mrs R.W. Goodlake

Eureka CA

Thank you Watson Well for saving our well!

When our well stopped producing water this summer, I called Watson Well. They used a special pump and opened up the well from 67’ to 132’. While inspecting the well with a video camera, they found that the wells steel casing had deteriorated in a number of places leaving large holes where sand and gravel were continuing to enter the well. They immediately installed a new liner and gravel packed the well. Our well has never produced this much water volume in twenty years of living on this property. We are also noticing a tremendous improvement in the quality of the water.

Susan Ashford

Don, his sons, and employees are all very knowledgeable and professional and did our projects at a very reasonable cost.

As Public Works Director for the Bear River Band of the Rohnerville Rancheria, I have contracted with Watson Well on five different projects for the tribe, here in Loleta, CA. Their company has completely replaced both of our main water systems submersible pumps and piping, which was not an easy task, as those wells are very deep. These projects were done very quickly and efficiently, while still maintaining a potable water supply to everyone at all times. They have the tools and equipment to not only handle the small jobs, but large jobs like this also. They have also installed three water softening units for us, as our water is very hard. These are big commercial units and all are working flawlessly. They have also developed a small rural water system for us on a piece of property the tribe recently purchased, to supply water to livestock. All of the work they have done for us is doing what they said it would do, without any problems or issues. Don, his sons, and employees are all very knowledgeable and professional and did our projects at a very reasonable cost. They stand behind their work and are only a phone call away. I would highly recommend Watson Well for any water project, no matter what the size, if you want it done right, on time and on budget, you won’t be disappointed.

Mike Flockhart, Director of Public Works

Bear River Band of the Rohnerville Rancheria

Thank you so much for the excellent response and care we have received. Your crew was courteous, prompt, clean, knowledgeable and very hard working!

It is hard to believe that it has been 9 months since I called you with an “out of water” problem on our property. It is not the call that any one on a well wants to make during a record breaking drought. You were here in a very short time and after taking in all the normal diagnostics you were concerned about us being dry but not convinced it was a true dry well. I think we were very fortunate that you had the ability to put a camera down our well to see what was happening and came up with a plan to rehabilitate our well after you discovered our weep holes for the well were plugged with iron bacteria, calcium and stuff. It gave us hope that we could get this reliable well up and running. You pulled the pump and line and determined that pump was fine. Once that was clear you put in the proper chemicals and literally scrubbed our well pipe of the “stuff” and found that our well was over 200’ deep. Water flowed and once the junk was sucked out of the well bottom and the chemicals neutralized we had 18’ more water which put us at over a 50’ column of water, of course this was fantastic. While here, all new water line and electrical wire was reinstalled and new electronics that were more current and a vast improvement of what we had. Since then the water keeps flowing with generous amounts and quality.

John and Elizabeth Ennis

Kneeland

I can only offer my highest praise for Don and his employees; thus I rank them 10 out of 10.

During the past two years, Watson Well has designed, constructed, and maintained a number of different projects at my home. These include new water storage tanks, a water treatment system, new piping from the pump house to the residence along with separate lines and faucets for untreated water; and a complex rain water catchment system including tanks, piping and faucets to different locations, all while providing flexibility directing the water to different areas as needed. Don Watson and his crew worked efficiently and coordinated the different aspects of the jobs in an effective manner. All systems continue to operate as expected without any problems. Don was always extremely helpful and receptive to new ideas which he easily incorporated into the projects.

Charles Compton

Copyright 2019 | Watson Well | 500 Summer St, Eureka, CA 95501 | (707) 442-2249
CA License #947596 | CA License #1014048 | C-57 | C-36

National Groundwater Association
California Groundwater Association